Evidence favoring the use of disciplinary spanking. Tennant even found that the childhood antecedents that were most associated with nonuse of illegal drugs by young men were being spanked as a child, attending church and having a happy parental marriage. Advantages and disadvantages of corporal punishment, essay. In a positive family setting, spanking has been found to be a positive predictor of outcome. Corporal punishment can be described as any physical action that hurts a child in the name of discipline. Corporal punishment and its effect on children 1587 words 7 pages. A 2002 study highlighted the many harmful consequences of corporal punishment, and clearly identified that corporal punishment has only one positive outcome. In 1990, research showing an association between physical punishment and negative developmental outcomes was starting to accumulate, and the convention on the rights of the. The objective of this study is to look at evidences worldwide and within the countries on corporal punishment in children and its adverse effects.
Mar 31, 2018 corporal punishment can be traumatizing to a child, says mojdeh bayat, a professor of early childhood education at depaul university. The use of physical punishment has been associated with many negative social outcomes, including aggression, disruptive behaviour in school, lack of acceptance by peers, crime and delinquency. The arguments for and against mainly revolve around the ethics and practicalities of using physical force as a way of maintaining student discipline. Apr 18, 2017 the advantages of corporal punishment in schools. The demise of corporal punishment is slow because of lack of clarity about effectiveness of different forms of child discipline. Longitudinal evidence from ethiopia, india, peru andviet nam. Research on the longterm effects of physical punishment are consistent, and overwhelmingly negative over a wide variety of child development outcomes. Nov 17, 2017 punishment is a fundamental concept used in the theory of operant conditioning. Corporal punishment can have a range of effects on children 2. The term corporal punishment is defined as the use of physical force with the intention of causing a child to experience pain, but not injury, for the purpose of correction or control of the childs behavior seven nations sweden, finland, denmark, norway, austria, italy and cyprushave laws making it illicit for parents. Whether practiced at home or in school, corporal punishment may indeed.
January, 09, 2011, a pastor expressed strong objection to the removal of corporal punishment in schools. The effect of corporal punishment in schools the new times. The effects of abolishing corporal punishment on learner. Claudien nzitabakuze, the head of teacher education management and professionalism department at reb, says adding to the rules and regulations regarding corporal punishment of children, is sensitisation regarding the issue. Pdf effects of corporal punishment on academic attainment of. Corporal punishment in school makes students take their studies seriously and also helps keep the students under control. The evidence that corporal punishment such as spanking, smacking, or slapping can impair child development is compelling. Students learn quickly that they feel pain for transgressions, literally. Among the two kinds of punishment, positive and negative, we are going to discuss positive punishment in this article. The government of the republic of uganda banned corporal punishment in 2006, but. This article addresses the impact of corporal punishment and its imprints on the psychological being of a student.
Corporal punishment is the process of utilizing negative reinforcement through inflicting physical pain to a child as a technique of availing punishment for doing wrong in school or at home. Can we imagine schools without corporal punishment. Although punishment sounds inherently negative, its not necessarily a negative thing. Of the public school population, 40,000or more than onethirdof those students who were subjected to corporal punishment were black. Get an answer for what are some advantages of corporal punishment. The advantages of corporal punishment legal beagle. The aacap recommends nonviolent methods of addressing inappropriate behavior in schools, such as behavior management and school wide positive behavior supports. Using positive discipline techniques in the classroom teachers positive discipline is a more effective way to manage misbehaving students in the classroom, rather than using punishment or rewards. The canadian paediatric society, therefore, recommends that physicians strongly discourage disciplinary spanking and all other forms of physical punishment. Physical redirection or restraint to support timeout or to prevent a child from harming himself or others may be necessary, but should be done carefully and without violence. The use of corporal punishment may pose both negative and positive effects in the zimbabwean education system whereas the complete negation of corporal punishment has its own detrimental and. Corporal and non corporal punishments are used in schools as a major.
Corporal punishment is also legal in private schools in 48 states, but the u. Corporal punishment, which involves the application of physical pain, was once the prevailing means of disciplining children, but research has called its efficacy into question. The word discipline means to impart knowledge and skill to teach. Sep 04, 2012 over the past two decades, we have seen an international shift in perspectives concerning the physical punishment of children. However, it is often equated with punishment and control. Effects of banning corporal punishment on discipline in. Evidence in wiehe 1990 suggests that there is a wait and see approach of the long term effects of corporal punishment on pupil discipline since neither side trust the evidence of the other. Each year, hundreds of thousands of students are subjected to corporal punishment in public schools. Nzitabakuze says schools are aware of these measures and most of them have adhered to them. A thorough analysis of concepts related to corporal punishment such as context of cp, relationship between cp and physical abuse, whether cp promotes or controls deviant behaviour. The wide spread practicability of corporal punishment at home and school made students to consider it as normal and acceptable. Talwar and colleagues compared children from a school that used positive. Clustered sampling technique was applied to identify the sample size for the study.
Arguments for and against the use of corporal punishment in. The longterm use of corporal punishment tends to increase the probability of deviant and antisocial behaviors, such as aggression. Over the past two decades, we have seen an international shift in perspectives concerning the physical punishment of children. Advantages and disadvantages of corporal punishment, essay sample. Reasons for corporal punishment of childrens in school. One of the positives seen in corporal punishment is the severe imposition of order in a setting that lacks elements of it. Some offenders may commit the offense anyway as the pain of corporal punishment is often temporary. There is also work to be done in the public sphere, gershoff says.
Compared to alternative methods of retribution such as expulsion, suspension, grounding or community service, corporal punishment has immediate effects. The effect of corporal punishment in schools the new. The effects of abolishing corporal punishment on learner behaviour in south african high schools. The discipline styles prevalence was in the 1970s, while presently, many countries engage in spirited discussions of the merits and demerits of this. The effects of corporal punishment on children how to adult. Effects of corporal punishment on children essay 868. Corporal punishment in schools university of missouri. Definition of corporal punishment the following definition, by the committee on the rights of the child, is the most widely accepted understanding of what we mean by corporal punishment. Punishment is a fundamental concept used in the theory of operant conditioning. There are extreme instances of corporal punishment practiced in schools that use tasers, chemical sprays, and leather straps. It is most often practised on minors, especially in home and school settings.
These negative effects on the brain can surely be connected to the increased aggression and externalization of behavior found in the other studies. The accumulated research shows convincingly that parents should adopt positive child. The problem of corporal punishment in schools has a significant correlation with youth mental health problems the objective of this study is to look at evidences worldwide and within the countries on corporal punishment in children and its adverse effects. Authorities are able to instill discipline in children through the use of corporal punishment in schools. The degree of trauma and its longterm effects, she adds. Consultations with children revealed the widespread use of corporal punishment and other forms of violence and abuse by teachers aimed to discipline students.
Jun 26, 2002 until researchers, clinicians, and parents can definitively demonstrate the presence of positive effects of corporal punishment, including effectiveness in halting future misbehavior, not just the absence of negative effects, we as psychologists can not responsibly recommend its use, gershoff writes. The proponents of corporal punishment argue that it is a great deterrent of misbehavior. The negative effects of corporal punishment and verbal abuse. People who are for corporal punishment in schools generally take the view that, if the physical force can be. The advantages of corporal punishment in schools how to. Corporal punishment signals to the child that a way to settle interpersonal conflicts is to use physical force and inflict pain. The ongoing use of corporal punishment in public schools. Corporal punishment, or punishment inflicting physical pain, is at best, a discipline of questionable effectiveness, and at worst, child abuse. Data collection was done in respect of the study specific objectives through data collection methods which include questionnaires and interviews. Department of educations office of civil rights does not collect discipline data from private schools. Corporal punishment is an effective way of disciplining many people. Corporal punishment in schools and its effect on academic success. It often involves striking the student either across the buttocks or palms of their hands with a tool such as a rattan cane, wooden paddle, slipper, leather strap or wooden yardstick. Most schools will practice corporal punishment through the use of paddling or a hand in the form of spanking.
Using positive discipline techniques in the classroom. Until researchers, clinicians, and parents can definitively demonstrate the presence of positive effects of corporal punishment, including effectiveness in halting future misbehavior, not just the absence of negative effects, we as psychologists can not. What are some positivesadvantages of corporal punishment. Assessing the effects of corporal punishment on primary. Promoting alternatives to corporal punishment legal assistance centre february 2016 1 promoting alternatives to corporal punishment the effects of corporal punishment some people think that corporal punishment is an effective and harmless means of disciplining children, but a.
This study examined the effects of corporal punishment cp in zanzibar primary schools. Corporal punishment or physical punishment is a tool materialized for controlling the behavior of a student for displaying. The state of research on the effects of physical punishment. It is used as a warning to show citizens the consequences behind some of the actions that certain people choose to execute. Jan 10, 2019 it is defined as a physical punishment which involves hitting someone. There is a great deal of controversy about the appropriate ways to discipline children, and parents are often confused about effective ways to. As to the effects of corporal punishment, the study addressed only its impact on education. Mar 01, 2016 this article presents an argument on the negative impact of corporal punishment. There is a low but significant positive relationship between personality development. These studies are just a handful of the increasing catalog of evidence against the use of corporal punishment.
Is corporal punishment an effective means of discipline. The lack of awareness of their fundamental human rights might make them to confirm the harsh school discipline without question. Any punishment in which physical force is used and intended to cause some degree of pain or discomfort, however light. Advantages and disadvantages of corporal punishment. It is a shortterm method of punishment that can be quickly administered in the home, school or in prison. A 2002 study highlighted the many harmful consequences of corporal punishment, and clearly identified that corporal punishment has only one positive outcome, and that this is a shortterm benefit. While an outright ban on spanking seems politically unlikely in the united states, she says, the passage of bans on physical punishment in schools has more public support corporal punishment in schools is legal in 19 states. It identified, discussed and analyzed data on various effects of cp on disciplining and academic performance of primary school pupils obtained from 125 study participants. The advantages of corporal punishment in schools how to adult. Corporal punishment is negatively associated with childrens later outcomes.
Effects of banning corporal punishment on discipline in south. It is a very sufficient method of keeping many of the populace under control. In operant conditioning, punishment is simply the discouragement of a behavior. The large body of research s the harmful impact of corporal punishment illustrates how. For example, a student may stop talking and disrupting a class for a while if the. Corporal punishment in schools is an emotional and controversial topic for many people.
The disadvantages outweigh the advantages to corporal punishment. It is also argued that corporal punishment negatively affects relationships and often creates resentment and hostility, which have been associated with school dropout and vandalism mwamawenda, 2008, p. In the absence of corporal punishment, children likely go wild. The positive impact of prohibition of corporal punishment on. Pdf corporal punishment and its effects in pakistan. The main objective of a punishment is to decrease the rate of certain undesired behavior from occurring again. It is defined as a physical punishment which involves hitting someone. Corporal punishment can be traumatizing to a child, says mojdeh bayat, a professor of early childhood education at depaul university.
246 872 116 1603 692 618 1544 318 944 610 1111 1532 259 654 1595 1527 1608 1375 881 511 313 815 1219 840 1031 1608 1008 314 19 480 1003 639 1224 867 763 1228 61 1118 523 537 308 93 400 843 691 1396